Skip to main content

Lanop

UK Supreme Court Rules on Corporation Tax Deductibility of Regulatory Redress Payments

UK Supreme Court tax deductibility ruling

ScottishPower has lost its fight to deduct around £28 million in regulatory redress payments from its Corporation Tax profits. The Supreme Court handed down its decision on 21 October 2026. All the judges agreed, and they sided with HMRC over the Court of Appeal. 

Businesses are still digesting the ruling this November. If your company has ever paid money to settle a breach with a regulator, you’ll want to see how that cost went through your tax return. 

Why Did the Supreme Court Reject ScottishPower’s £28 Million Tax Claim? 

Ofgem, the energy regulator, looked into ScottishPower after problems with sales practices, customer complaints, pricing, and energy-saving duties. 

ScottishPower avoided big fines by signing four settlement agreements. Under them, it agreed to pay roughly £28 million to customers and charities. Each deal also came with a £1 penalty. 

The company called the money compensation, not a fine, and took it off its taxable profits. HMRC said no. The Supreme Court has now backed HMRC, so none of the £28 million can be deducted. 

Why Are Regulatory Redress Payments Not Tax-Deductible? 

Section 54 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009 sets the test. A cost is deductible only if the business incurred it wholly and exclusively for its trade. 

The Court looked at the reason behind the payments. ScottishPower paid to settle regulatory breaches and avoid larger penalties. That doesn’t count as an expense of running the trade. 

Even the £554,013 sent directly to affected customers failed. It sat inside the wider settlement, so the Court treated it the same way. 

Labels don’t decide this. Call a payment compensation, redress, or a refund, and it still may not earn tax relief. 

What Does This Mean for UK Businesses? 

Energy firms aren’t the only ones to worry. Banks, insurers, telecoms companies, and anyone else working under a regulator could face the same issue. 

Say your company agrees to pay customers instead of taking a fine. Don’t assume HMRC will let you deduct it. 

A refused deduction raises your taxable profit, and your tax bill goes up with it. The exact amount depends on your figures and the Corporation Tax rate you pay. Get a claim wrong and you could also owe interest and penalties on top. 

Are Customer Refunds Still Tax-Deductible? 

The Court left one question open. Before the settlements, ScottishPower had separately written off about £8 millions of customer bills. The judges didn’t say whether those write-offs were deductible. 

So, keep two things apart in your own books. Everyday customer refunds are one thing. Payments you agree as part of regulatory action are another. Some refunds will still be fine for tax. It comes down to why you made them and what was happening at the time. 

What Should Businesses Do Following the Ruling? 

Start by going back through your past Corporation Tax returns. Look for any deduction linked to a regulatory settlement. 

You can usually amend a return within 12 months of its filing deadline. For older periods where you’ve underpaid, think about whether you should tell HMRC. 

Keep your paperwork in order as well. Hold on to settlement agreements, refund details, and a note of why each payment was made. 

How Can Lanop Help? 

This decision is a good reason to check regulatory payments before you claim relief on them. 

Lanop’s tax advisors can go through your Corporation Tax deductions, show you where you might be exposed, and tell you whether any past returns need correcting. 

You’ll get practical advice and a clear next step, so you can deal with the risk and move on with confidence. 

Need Clarity on What to Do Next?

Speak to a Lanop expert for a free review of your position and the action required.
Free Consultation Call

Book Your FREE Consultation with a Tax Advisor

Enter Your Name & Email Address for a Free Consultation